Human Rights and the Rights of the Child
Civic Education · WAEC · SS2 and SS3
Human rights are the claims a person has simply by being human, and Chapter IV of the Constitution turns the main ones into enforceable Nigerian law. The child-rights half of this topic rests on the Child's Rights Act 2003, which fixes eighteen as the age of a child.
What you need to know
- Human rights are universal, inalienable, indivisible and interdependent. They belong to everyone regardless of tribe, religion or status, cannot be transferred or surrendered, and cannot be ranked one above another.
- Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution runs from section 33 to section 46. In order: right to life, right to dignity of the human person, right to personal liberty, right to fair hearing, right to private and family life, freedom of thought conscience and religion, freedom of expression and the press, right to peaceful assembly and association, right to freedom of movement, freedom from discrimination, and the right to acquire and own immovable property anywhere in Nigeria.
- Section 44 protects a person from having property compulsorily taken without prompt payment of adequate compensation and a right of access to court. Section 45 sets the limits, and section 46 gives the High Court special jurisdiction to hear a citizen who says his rights have been breached.
- Rights are not absolute. Section 45 allows laws that restrict them in the interest of defence, public safety, public order, public morality, public health, or to protect the rights and freedoms of other persons. That is why a curfew, a quarantine order or a ban on a noisy procession can stand.
- During a declared state of emergency further derogation is permitted, but the Constitution does not allow the right to life to be set aside except for deaths resulting from acts of war, and it does not permit a person to be punished under a law that did not exist when the act was done.
- Classification you should be able to reel off: civil and political rights such as life, liberty and voting; economic, social and cultural rights such as work, education and health; and collective or solidarity rights such as the right to development, to a clean environment and to self-determination.
- Internationally the foundation is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on 10 December 1948, which is why that date is Human Rights Day. Africa adds the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights, adopted in 1981 at Banjul and domesticated in Nigeria by an Act of the National Assembly, which is unusual because it gives the Charter force in Nigerian courts.
- The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child was adopted in 1989 and the African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child in 1990. Nigeria gave domestic effect to them through the Child's Rights Act of 2003.
- The Child's Rights Act 2003 defines a child as any person under the age of eighteen. It sets the minimum age of marriage at eighteen, prohibits child betrothal, outlaws the use of children in criminal activity and in hazardous labour, forbids tattooing and skin marking of children, and makes the best interest of the child the paramount consideration in every decision.
- Because child welfare is on the residual list, the federal Act binds the Federal Capital Territory, and each state must pass its own version for it to apply there. Most states have now done so, but domestication was slow and uneven, especially in parts of the north, which is why child marriage prosecutions differ from state to state.
- Children's rights group into four: survival rights such as life, food, shelter and health care; development rights such as education, play and leisure; protection rights against abuse, neglect, trafficking and exploitation; and participation rights, including the right to be heard in matters affecting the child.
- Children also carry duties. The law expects a child to work towards the cohesion of the family, to respect parents, superiors and elders, to place his abilities at the service of the nation and to preserve Nigerian cultural values.
- Enforcement bodies in Nigeria are the courts under the Fundamental Rights Enforcement Procedure Rules, the National Human Rights Commission established in 1995, the Legal Aid Council for citizens who cannot afford a lawyer, the Public Complaints Commission acting as ombudsman against administrative injustice, and NAPTIP for trafficking of women and children.
- Threats to human rights in Nigeria that WAEC expects you to name concretely are unlawful arrest and detention beyond the constitutional time limit, extrajudicial killing, torture to extract confessions, jungle justice, child labour and street hawking, almajiri destitution, female genital mutilation, forced and early marriage, and suppression of peaceful protest.
Key terms
- Human rights
- The basic entitlements every person holds by virtue of being human, which the state is bound to respect, protect and fulfil.
- Fundamental human rights
- The subset of human rights written into Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution, which a citizen can enforce directly in the High Court.
- Derogation
- The lawful suspension or reduction of a right in a defined emergency, permitted only within the limits the Constitution sets.
- Child
- Under the Child's Rights Act 2003, any person who has not attained the age of eighteen years.
- Best interest of the child
- The legal standard requiring that in every action concerning a child, the child's welfare comes before every other consideration.
- Fair hearing
- The right to be told the case against you, to be heard before a decision is taken, and to be judged by an impartial tribunal within a reasonable time.
- Child abuse
- Any act or failure to act by a parent, guardian or other adult that harms or threatens a child's physical, emotional or moral well-being.
Worked examples
A police officer arrests Musa, keeps him in a cell for two weeks without charge and refuses him access to a lawyer. Identify the rights breached and state the remedy open to him. (10 marks)
- Take the facts one at a time and match each to a named right rather than giving a general answer about human rights.
- Detention without charge touches the right to personal liberty; the refusal of a lawyer and the absence of a charge touch the right to fair hearing; prolonged cell conditions may touch the right to dignity of the human person.
- For the remedy, name the forum, the procedure and what the court can give.
Answer: The rights breached are the right to personal liberty, because the Constitution requires a detained person to be brought before a court within a short constitutionally fixed period; the right to fair hearing, because he was neither informed of a charge nor allowed counsel of his choice; and the right to dignity of the human person if the detention conditions were degrading. His remedy is to apply to the High Court of the state or the Federal High Court under the Fundamental Rights Enforcement Procedure Rules for an order of release, a declaration that the detention was unlawful, an apology and compensation. He may also petition the National Human Rights Commission and the Police Service Commission.
State five provisions of the Child's Rights Act 2003. (10 marks)
- Begin with the definition clause, since the age of eighteen is the anchor of the whole Act.
- Then pick provisions from different areas: marriage, labour, criminal use, protection and education, so the examiner sees range.
- Write each as a provision of the Act, not as an opinion about children.
Answer: It defines a child as a person under eighteen years. It fixes eighteen as the minimum age of marriage and voids child marriage and betrothal. It prohibits the use of a child in hazardous labour or in any work that interferes with education. It forbids the use of children in criminal activities such as hawking of drugs or begging. It prohibits tattooing and skin marking of a child. It makes the best interest of the child the paramount consideration in every matter concerning the child, and guarantees the child free, compulsory and universal basic education.
The mistake to avoid
Candidates list rights without the limits, then lose marks on the second half of the question, which almost always asks when a right may lawfully be restricted. The other trap is treating the Child's Rights Act as automatically binding in every state. It is federal legislation that each state must adopt, and that is the correct answer whenever a question asks why child marriage is still prosecuted differently across Nigeria.
In the exam
Scenario questions dominate here: a short story is given and you must name the right breached and the remedy. Name the right in the Constitution's own words, for example right to personal liberty rather than freedom to move about. Where a remedy is asked, say High Court, Fundamental Rights Enforcement Procedure Rules, and the specific order sought, because each of those is a separate mark.